| BACK TO
THE ESSAYS PAGE
An
Interpretation of David Lynch's Eraserhead
By VanCleve
Taggart
The
film opens with the image of a planetoid partially obscured by a floating,
diaphanous likeness of the main character HENRY. Cut to a shot panning across
the surface of the planetoid until it reaches a metal shack with a hole in
the roof. POV lowers through the hole. Inside the shack, looking out a broken
window, is the character I will call the CONTROLLER. He is covered with something
like barnacles, suggesting that he is ancient, long-established. The Henry-likeness
opens its mouth and "births" a tadpole-like fetus. The Controller's
arm twitches and then pulls several levers, which apparently cause the fetus
to move away from the Henry image and splash down in a puddle. The swirling
bubbles in the puddle are shown in close-up; tiny bright specks against a
dark background, like the starlit black sky surrounding the planetoid; first
examples
of an image which recurs throughout the film. Then there is a shot of an
opening surrounded by darkness. POV moves towards the opening, reversing
the earlier
entering-the-hole-in-roof POV, (i.e. leaving the Controller's realm?).
Cut
to actual, non-likeness Henry, looking back (as though at the opening's
exterior) with a concerned expression. What is his relation to the
first
scene? He turns and heads off through an urban wasteland. He accidently
steps in a
puddle, like the puddle into which the fetus fell (fallen into a wasteland?).
He enters his apartment building and checks his mailbox, which is empty.
He gets into the elevator and waits a long time for the door to close.
Does this
wait lend significance to where the elevator is taking him? Outside his
door an attractive female NEIGHBOR tells him that Mary called and
asked him to
dinner.
Henry enters his
bizarre and shabby room. There is evidence of uncontrolled organic
growth is several places, like beneath the radiator. A sick-looking
miniature tree growing out of a muddy mound is on a night stand next
to
his bed. There is a little cabinet attached to the wall. The anticipatory
wait
in the elevator makes us pay close attention to these details. Henry
opens a dresser drawer and takes out a torn picture of Mary.
Cut to Henry crossing
more urban wasteland. He is met at the front door of Mary's house
by perpetually-anxious MARY and her MOTHER.
They retire to the
living room for some monumentally uncomfortable small talk. Mary has
a brief convulsive fit after Mother asks Henry the question; "What
did you do?".
We meet Mary's FATHER, a morbid cartoon version of a blue collar worker.
He says he has seen this home's neighborhood turn from "pastures
to the hell hole it is now". Mary's house is filled with examples
of gross or decaying life-forms; a dog nursing a flock of noisily
ravenous puppies, dead or uncontrollably
proliferating plants, Mary's senile-catatonic GRANDMOTHER. The overall
impression, looking past the deadpan, sick-black hilarity, is of
something gone terribly
wrong with Nature (a world turned into a wasteland). They adjourn to
the dinner table where Henry is invited to carve up a tiny "man-made" baked
chicken. When he touches it with his fork, the chicken's legs begin to
move uncontrollably up and down as it "menstruates" out
of its tail-end orifice. This gynecological grossness sends Mother
into a convulsive fit, which
recalls Mary's fit and also associates to the twitching eyes of her Father.
Are these movements also related to the twitching arm of the ancient
Controller, perhaps a suggestion that Mary's family is somehow acting
under his control?
After regaining her composure, Mother takes Henry aside. We see a lamp
flicker on and off several times before shorting out. She questions
Henry about his
sex life with Mary (recalling Mary's response to Mother's question; "What
did you do?"). Henry recoils as Mother interrupts her words about
sex to deliver an open-mouthed (grossly unnatural) kiss to his neck.
Mary enters
and pulls Mother off Henry. Mother says that there is a premature baby
at the hospital and that Henry is the father. Henry says a baby is impossible,
his
sexual activity with Mary was for too recent. Mother tells Henry it is
time for him to marry (the never merry) Mary, that he will be in trouble
if he "doesn't
cooperate" (with the Controller?).
Cut to Mary feeding
the BABY in Henry's room. The delicate infant, looking like the hybridization
of
an extraterrestrial and a mucous membrane (maturing
tadpole-fetus?), perpetually makes demands. We see Henry go down to
his mailbox, where he finds a tiny package. He walks outside with
it (hiding
it from Mary
and the Baby) and unwraps a tiny slug-like creature. He hides it in
his pocket before returning to his room, where we witness the couple's
perverse
attempts
at domesticity. Mary frets over the groaning, wailing Baby. She grows
increasingly frustrated as Henry half-heartedly tries to look like
a proud father. Neither
seem capable of embodying their parental roles. Henry stares at the
radiator and sees a tiny stage gradually light up behind it. The
stage fades away
as Mary asks him if there was any mail (contact with the rest of the
world?). Henry lies and says no.
Later, Mary is
in bed. Before joining her, Henry takes the slug out of the pocket
of his coat and puts
it inside the small cabinet that
hangs
on the wall,
making sure that Mary is not watching him. When he gets into bed,
Mary recoils from his touch. The Baby will not stop wailing. After
several
failed attempts
at quieting the Baby, Mary gets hysterical and tells Henry she is
leaving. We see her make another strange convulsive movement, (Controller-resonant?)
at the foot of the bed. It is finally revealed that Mary is pulling
out her suitcase. She leaves (as directed by the Controller?). Henry
does not
seem
disappointed. He leans back on the bed and looks up at the ceiling.
We then see an image of the attractive Neighbor walking down the
hall
(a fantasy
of
Henry's?).
Later, Henry, wondering
if the Baby is sick, checks its temperature. Everything looks "normal" until the Baby suddenly
screams and is instantaneously covered with festering sores. Wrapped
in swaddling
clothes, born of a woman
named Mary, conceived under biologically impossible circumstances,
the Baby is now receiving a gross version of Christ-referencing stigmata.
Apparently
the Baby is an enormously important entity; "immaculately" conceived
(diaphanous fetus image), related to the Controller (who lives on
a planetoid; non-earthly realm) whose lever-pull caused the fetus
(Baby) to descend into
the puddle (wasteland Earth). Henry has been handed a staggering
responsibility, one he didn't ask for; keeping the fragile Baby alive.
Mary and her family,
under the Controller's direction, have left the Baby with Henry,
its "chosen" care-giver/parent
(explaining the presence of his floating likeness, viewed (projected?)
by the Controller through his window during the "mouth-birthing" scene).
Perhaps Henry's nerdishness, his inability to completely invest himself
in or fully identify with the ways of the (wasteland) world can be
construed as
a vague glimmer of potential spirituality; the reason why he was "chosen".
He tries to help the afflicted Baby, absurdly providing a vaporizer,
but nothing works. He sits by the Baby, listless. Then he gets up
and goes to
the little
wall cabinet and opens it briefly, revealing the slug he found in
the mailbox. But the Baby only cries more loudly when Henry leaves
its side
(the slug
and the Baby are in some way oppositional). Henry returns to the
Baby, looking profoundly trapped.
Later, in bed,
Henry looks at the radiator. Again the little stage lights up.
POV moves in on the stage as the RADIATOR WOMAN comes
in from the
wings and
begins to dance. Her exaggeratedly broad cheeks suggest an artificial
cheerfulness. Numerous tadpole-fetuses begin to fall from the ceiling,
(an obligation
from Above?). Maintaining her innocent smile, the Radiator Woman
begins to squash
them with her feet (refusing to fulfill the obligation?). Cut to
Henry in bed. Was he dreaming or was he somehow connected, conduit-like,
through the
radiator
to a tempting alternative space outside his room? Mary is back in
his
bed. She begins to give birth to numerous tadpole-fetuses. Is Henry
dreaming now? Or is the dream/non-dream ambiguity making a point?
The sense that "this
can NOT be happening but IS happening" seems to pervade ERASERHEAD.
The audience can never be certain whether it is viewing a dream,
a fantasy, waking
reality or some sort of metaphysical realm, even as the film's various
settings refer to and transition into one another. The seemingly
intentional non-resolution
of these contextual uncertainites creates an overall sense of implausible,
yet non-dismissible, threat. Henry, disgusted, throws the fetuses
away. Would Henry have destroyed them if he had not first been given "permission" by
the fetus-stomping Radiator Woman? They smash against the wall near
the little cabinet. Then the cabinet doors open by themselves. The
slug inside the cabinet
begins to move.Cut to the slug frolicking (rebelliously?) on the
surface of the Controller's planetoid. Perhaps the slug is a distilled
version
of Henry's
under-developed (undersized) enjoyment-seeking self, linked (through
the mailbox) to the non-spiritual aspirations of the world. The slug
stops moving and opens
itself up into an orifice-shape. POV enters the orifice (into the
slug's "inner
world"). We next see the bright-flecks-on-dark image. This image
turns out to be speckling on a dark wall (like the night sky, the
transportation medium between planetoid and Earth; i.e. an image
related to movement,
transition,
change of setting). POV lowers through a hole in the wall (a second "orifice")
through which we see Henry, seated on his bed in his room. The lighting
now seems darker and more muted (a visually flatter, perhaps more
metaphorical version of Henry's life-setting). POV has passed through
two orifices;
an
externalization of the slug's internal perspective. It seems we are
about to see slug-Henry's
perspective on controlled, marginally loyal, Baby-caregiver Henry's
situation.
There
is a knock on Henry's door. He rises from his bed and answers.
He sees nothing
for a few moments, but then his comely Neighbor
appears, dream-like,
out of darkness. She explains that she has locked herself out. As she
talks Henry tries to stifle the Baby's crying. She seductively
asks if she can
stay with him until morning. They end up having sex in a milky pool
(puddle) which
has replaced Henry's bed, neglecting the Baby. They sink beneath the
surface (into the wasteland). Through an image of parting milky
liquid we briefly
see a night sky (transition), the Neighbor in deep shadow, the planetoid
and then
the Neighbor disappearing into shadows (the slug's perspective; Henry's
fantasies about the Neighbor are hopelessly insubstantial)
to be replaced by the Radiator
Woman on her stage, singing; "In heaven everything is fine. You've
got your good things and I've got mine. In heaven everythig is fine.
You've got
your good things and YOU'VE got mine." Henry steps up onto the
stage and approaches her. She encourages him. But when he touches her
he is blinded by
light. He tries again with the same result. There is the suggestion
that Henry is engaging in behavior considered neglectful and self-involved
from the viewpoint
of the Controller ("you've got your good things and you've got
mine";
you have received the special Baby, but you are only concerned with
you own mundane wishes). Then the Radiator Woman disappears. She is
briefly replaced
by the Controller, source of the restricting light (which recalls the
flickering light at Mary's house, occurring when Henry was about to
find out about the
Controller's Baby). Then we see a wind come up and blow away the tadpole-fetuses
left over from the Radiator Woman's "squashing" scene. An
enlarged version of the sickly tree seen next to Henry's bed slides
onto the stage.
Henry retreats behind a chest-high curtain. The tree begins to bleed.
Henry's suddenly inanimate head pops off and falls onto the floor.
The Baby's head
sprouts out of Henry's shoulders. (Henry's obligations to the Baby
have objectified him (inanimate head)). Henry's head falls through
the bloody
(puddle) floor
and lands in a vacant lot (wasteland). The position of the head on
the ground is matched to the head position of a nearby derelict (discarded
objects).
A little BOY finds the head and takes it to a questionable-looking
office.
It
is passed to a TECHNICIAN who takes a core sample (raw material) of
the head and then feeds this head-core into a machine which converts
the
raw material
into pencil-top erasers (commodity), which physically remind us of
the goofy stacked hair that tops Henry's body. This downward progression
(person-object-discarded
object-raw material-commodity) is the slug's perspective on Henry's
life
since the Baby came into it; ultimately associating him with erasure
(turned into
an overburdened child-care-providing commodity erased from the concerns
of Mary and the rest of the world). Of course, this progression could
alternately
be seen (from a more selfless perspective) as a failed opportunity.
The trials that Henry has involuntarily gone through could have been
used
to erase his
self-concern and turn him into the nurturer of an entity perhaps capable
of erasing the world's grossness and decay. Henry, in this process,
would have
assumed some of the qualities of the exceptional Baby himself, a positive
take on the juxtaposition of Henry's body with the Baby's head. But
this has not
occurred. Could he have reasonably been expected to successfully care
for the Baby? Is the slug's perspective deserving of unqualified condemnation?
A great
deal was asked of Henry by the barnacled Controller whose broken windows
(fading vision?) and damaged roof (failing mind?) suggest a deteriorating,
misdirected
quasi-God. The Technician brushes shavings off his pencil machine.
They fall in slow motion (another repeat of the transition-signaling
bright-flecks-on-black
image).
Cut to Henry in
bed, waking (?) from the slug-perspective "dream" that
has generated a devastating summary of his life. Later, in daylight,
an immobilized Henry looks around his room. Even later, with it dark
outside, he gets up,
goes across the room and watches, through his window, an assault which
is occurring near a puddle (repellent wasteland behavior). He backs
away from
the window,
works up courage while hoping that the Baby will stay quiet and goes
out to knock on the Neighbor's door. There is no answer. He comes back
into his
room.
The Baby starts making a noise that sounds like mocking laughter (at
Henry's attempts to fulfill his mundane fantasies?). He lies down on
his bed. The
Fats Waller music that he plays on his phonograph and which accompanies
the scenes
with the Radiator Woman is faintly heard. But he does not look to the
radiator (after seeing himself (by experiencing the slug's perspective)
restricted
by the Controller from making contact with the Radiator Woman). The
Baby laughs
some more. The doors of the little cabinet on the wall stay shut (suggesting
that the slug has completed its goal, Henry has adopted the slug's
non-spiritual agenda). The organ music fades away. Then there is a
noise in the hallway.
Henry rushes to the door. The Neighbor is in the company of a jaded-looking
MAN with a large bruise or birthmark on his face (Nature gone wrong).
The Man starts to grope the Neighbor. Apparently she is a whore (puddle
dweller,
seen
moving into and out of darkness). Next is perhaps a Henry-fantasy from
the Neighbor's POV which pictures (like in the slug-perspective) the
Baby's head
on Henry's body (i.e. how Baby-saddled he looks in the eyes of the
Neighbor; no notion in Henry or the Neighbor of the Baby's importance).
Henry shuts
the door. All of his outlets (Neighbor, Radiator Woman, the world outside
his window)
are closed off to him. He sees himself as alone with his overwhelming
obligations to the Baby. Henry gets a pair of scissors out of his dresser.
He goes over to the Baby, cuts open its swaddling clothes and stabs
it in the heart. The
Baby goes through appropriately miraculous death throes, ejecting huge
amounts of blood and a mud-like slurry. Its neck elongates above the
slurry mound,
recalling the sickly tree by Henry's bed (the wasteland world was,
in a feebly-implemented Controller act, given a special, but sickly
Son (to metaphorically rise above
the wasteland) who bleeds like the enlarged version of the tree that
bled in the slug's "dream"). The floor lamp is shorting out,
blinking off and on (like the foreshadowing lamp at Mary's house).
The Baby's head
miraculously
enlarges and moves in concert with the flickering brightness (the Controller's
brightness, which kept Henry from the anti-Baby Radiator Woman in the
slug-perspective, is shown here as losing its control-ability; Henry's
stabbing has "short-circuited" a
conduct-related boundary enforced by the faltering Controller). As
the lamp goes dark, the Baby's head moves accusingly close to the cowering,
failed
care-giver
Henry. Cut to the planetoid. We see Henry (in a sense fleeing the scene
of the crime) surrounded by transitional, transportational swirling
particles-in-darkness.
Part of the planetoid surface breaks up and falls away, leaving an
opening which POV moves into (like entering the roof hole in the opening
scene while
also reversing the out-of-orifice, birth-suggesting movements in the
opening "mouth-birth" scene
and "man-made" (Son of Man) wiggling chicken scene; considered
together, an indication that the Baby has been un-conceived (erased)).
We see the Controller
struggle with his levers and then collapse (a failure, having sent
the ill-prepared world his only begotten, high-maintainance Baby).
The restricting brightness
that kept Henry from the Radiator Woman returns, but this time Henry
can see the Radiator Woman through it (Controller has now totally lost
control).
They
reach eachother and embrace (unfortunate alliance). Through the process
of seeking a self-focused "heaven" ("you've got your
good things and you've got mine"), to escape his harshly imposed
responsibility to the Baby, out-of-his-depth Henry did not actualize
the one remote
possibility (devotion to the Baby) for the success of the Controller's
improbable plan
for bringing some form of hope to wasteland Earth (its decay a reflection
of
the state of the Controller). So everything is NOT fine as ERASERHEAD
reaches its catastrophic conclusion. BACK
TO TOP | BACK TO ESSAYS |